Most Popular
The Classic
Butterkase cheese, fresh baked white sourdough bread & fresh butter.$7.50
The Southport
Butterkase cheese & smoked onion marmalade.$8.50
The Little Italy
Butterkase cheese, five cheese garlic spread, heirloom tomato salsa & pepperoni.$10.50
Lobster Friday Special
The Sebastian
Double Butterkase cheese & fresh lobster. Available on Friday's only$16.50
Sandwiches
The Classic
Butterkase cheese, fresh baked white sourdough bread & fresh butter.$7.50
On The Lighter Side
A box filled with a small grilled cheese, small tomato pesto soup (contains pine nuts) & a few of our house made potato chips.$10.50
The Duke
Swiss cheese, ham & your choice of toppings: beer mustard (brown), blueberry mustard with slices of fresh peach (seasonal - only available in July), cranberry mustard, pear almond conserve, poblano mustard(yellow), rhubarb mustard, spiced cranberry marmalade.$11.50
The Breakfast Club #1
Double Butterkase cheese, farm fresh egg, pork sausage & pure maple syrup.$13.50
The Breakfast Club #2
Swiss cheese, farm fresh egg, turkey sausage, & smoked onion marmalade.$13.50
The Breakfast Club #3
Double White cheddar cheese, farm fresh egg, bacon & pure maple syrup.$13.50
The Little Italy
Butterkase cheese, five cheese garlic spread, heirloom tomato salsa & pepperoni.$10.50
The Little Italy (No Pepperoni)
Butterkase cheese, five cheese garlic spread & heirloom tomato salsa.$9.50
The Southport
Butterkase cheese & smoked onion marmalade.$8.50
The Blue Buffalo
Butterkase cheese, buffalo chicken & blue cheese.$13.50
The Pulled Porker
Butterkäse cheese, BBQ pulled pork & fresh market slaw (usually diced honey crisp apples and diced carrots - added after cooking the grilled cheese for a cool, sweet, crunchy taste)$14.50
The River Valley
Swiss cheese, smoked onion marmalade & sauteed fresh mushrooms.$9.50
The Sweetie Pie
Swiss cheese, raspberry jam & fresh roasted pecans.$10.50
The Chibano
Similar to a Cubano but the Chicago version. Made with fresh bread, fresh butter, double Prairie Pure swiss cheese, Jake’s Country Meats ham & pork, Duke’s Alehouse beer mustard, and Bushel & Peck’s bread and butter pickles. Yes, this one is hearty and delicious.$16.50
The Gobler
Double white cheddar cheese from Prairie Pure Cheese, turkey from Slagel Farm, fresh spinach from the local farmers market and our house made cranberry jam made with fresh cranberries from Ellis Farm.$14.50
The Classic Mac
Our Classic grilled cheese with our house made Mac-n-cheese inside.$10.00
The Abreo
White cheddar cheese, honey crisp apple slices & bacon onion jam. Seasonal - available August through April$10.50
The Jake
Gouda cheese, ham & apple butter. Seasonal - available August through April$12.50
Soup & Sides
Chips
Our house made potato chips$2.00
Tomato Pesto Soup
Made fresh with all veggies. It is not a cream based soup. Contains pine nuts.$2.50
Our House Made Mac & Cheese
Delicious macaroni & cheese made in house. So creamy and delicious!!$3.50
Loop Soup
A bowl of our delicious tomato pesto soup with an extra crispy Classic cut into small pieces to put in your soup like a cracker, but cheesier!$13.00
Desserts
Cookie
A variety of great flavors made locally by Cookie Yum!$2.50
2 Cookies
Save $1 and get 2! Twice as delicious!!$4.00
Beverages
Water
In an Aluminum can!! No plastic here :)$2.25
Filbert's Soda
A variety of flavors to choose from. Made here in Chicago on Ashland Avenue. Support local :)$2.50
Filbert's Ginger Beer
Made here in Chicago on Ashland Avenue! Support local :)$3.00
Iced SenTEAmental Moods Tea
A locally made tea. Unsweetened$3.00
Hot SenTEAmental Moods Tea
Choose from a variety of flavors. Made locally here in Chicago.$3.00
Hot Chocolate
Made with locally made marshmallows.$3.00
Coffee
We use Intelligentsia Coffee$2.50
